Toyota Supra vs Nissan Fairlady Z: Two Old Names, Two Very Different Ideas of a Sports Car
The GR Supra borrowed its bones from BMW. The Fairlady Z kept faith with a big Nissan V6 and a manual gearbox. From Japan, both arrive right-hand drive and usually cherished.
By the Japan to Ireland editors · · 4 min read


In short: In the three months to 19 September 2026, 110 Toyota Supras sold at Japanese auctions at a median of €33,264, against 600 Nissan Fairlady Zs at €5,965. The Nissan Fairlady Z is the cheaper buy by about €27,299 at auction, before shipping, VAT, VRT and fees. Our verdict is at the end of this article.
For most of the 2000s, Japan's two most famous sports car names went in opposite directions. Nissan kept the Fairlady Z in production almost without a break, refining the same front-engined, rear-drive formula. Toyota let the Supra lapse in 2002 and brought it back seventeen years later in a way that unsettled some of its fans: as a joint project with BMW, built in Austria alongside the Z4.
Both cars are now easy to find at Japanese auctions. The Supra in question is the A90 GR Supra, sold from 2019. The Fairlady Z is the Z34, sold for an unusually long fourteen years from 2008, and its 2022 successor, known internally as the RZ34, which keeps much of the old car's structure under a new body and a new engine. For an Irish buyer, these are three different cars, and the right choice depends on what you want a sports car to do.
The specs
| Toyota Supra | Nissan Fairlady Z | |
|---|---|---|
| Generation most imported | GR Supra (A90), 2019 on | Z34, 2008–2022; RZ34, 2022 on |
| Engine(s) | 2.0 four-cylinder turbo; 3.0 straight-six turbo | 3.7 V6 (Z34); 3.0 twin-turbo V6 (RZ34) |
| Power | 197 or 258 PS (2.0); 340, later 387 PS (3.0) | 336 PS (Z34); 405 PS (RZ34) |
| Gearbox | 8-speed automatic; 6-speed manual on 3.0 from 2022 | 6-speed manual or 7-speed auto (Z34); 6-speed manual or 9-speed auto (RZ34) |
| Drive | Rear | Rear |
| Seats | 2 | 2 |
| Length | 4,380 mm | 4,260 mm (Z34); 4,380 mm (RZ34) |
| Import duty to Ireland | 0% possible (Japan-built, with proof of origin) | 0% possible (Japan-built, with proof of origin) |
History and positioning
The GR Supra uses a BMW platform and BMW engines, with Toyota responsible for the styling, the chassis tuning and much of the character. Japanese buyers could choose the SZ and SZ-R with a 2.0-litre four-cylinder, or the RZ with a 3.0-litre straight-six. The six was uprated in 2020, and a six-speed manual became available in 2022.
The Z34 is an older, more mechanical machine. Its 3.7-litre naturally aspirated V6 is loud and strong, and the manual gearbox has a rev-matching function that blips the throttle on downshifts. The RZ34 adds a twin-turbo 3.0 V6 shared with the Skyline 400R, and a retro design that nods to the original 1969 car.
How they drive
The Supra 3.0 is fast in a smooth, precise way. The straight-six pulls hard from low revs, the eight-speed automatic is quick, and the short wheelbase makes the car feel agile. It is stable on the motorway and civilised enough for daily use. The 2.0 is lighter at the front and sweeter in corners, though it lacks the six's sound and urgency.
The Z34 is more physical. Its steering is heavier, its engine more raw, and the cabin fills with noise at high revs. It is a car you drive with your shoulders. The RZ34 is notably quicker and more refined, but still feels old-school compared with the Supra. On a wet, bumpy Irish back road, both cars need respect: they are powerful, rear-wheel drive and run wide tyres.
Inside and practicality
The Supra's cabin is mostly BMW switchgear and infotainment, which makes it feel well built and modern, if not distinctively Toyota. Visibility is poor at the rear and the low roofline makes getting in awkward for tall drivers. The boot, under a hatchback, is reasonable for a weekend away.
The Z34 interior is dated, with hard plastics and three dials on top of the dashboard that are a lovely period touch. The RZ34 adds a digital instrument panel and better materials. Both Zs have a usable boot, although a strut brace eats into the space on the Z34.
Running costs and reliability
Neither is cheap to tax in Ireland, as both sit in the high CO2 bands, and the 2.0 Supra is the least punishing on that front. Insurance should be checked before bidding. The Supra's BMW engine and gearbox are well proven, and parts can be sourced through both Toyota and BMW channels.
The Z34's VQ37 engine is durable but early cars suffered from oil gallery gasket failures, and manual cars are known for problems with the clutch slave cylinder. Both are well documented and fixable. The RZ34 is too new for a long track record.

What to check at a Japanese auction
Sports cars attract modification. Read the auction sheet for notes on aftermarket exhausts, lowered suspension and ECU tuning, all of which can complicate the NCT and affect insurance. Look for grade 4 or higher cars with clear records.
For the Supra, check for kerbed wheels and front splitter damage, which are common on such a low car. For the Z34, look at the clutch feel and any notes about oil leaks, and ask about the gasket and slave cylinder history. Rust is rare on these cars, but inspect the underbody for scrapes.
The verdict
Buy the Supra if you want a modern, refined sports car with strong performance and everyday comfort. The 3.0 is the one to have for pace; the 2.0 is a sweeter, more economical drive.
Buy the Z34 if you want a raw, mechanical sports car with a big engine and a manual gearbox, and you are happy to live with older technology. Buy the RZ34 if you want that character with modern power and design, and can find one at the right price.
Frequently asked questions
Is the GR Supra a BMW?
It shares its platform and engines with the BMW Z4 and is built in Austria, but Toyota styled it and tuned its chassis.
Which Fairlady Z should I import?
The Z34 is the most common and affordable. The RZ34, from 2022, is faster and more modern but rarer.
Is there a manual Supra?
Yes. A six-speed manual became available on the 3.0 RZ from 2022.
Which is easier to live with every day?
The Supra, thanks to its smoother ride, modern cabin and automatic gearbox.
Keep reading
- Toyota GR Yaris vs Subaru WRX STI: The New Rally Hero Meets the Old One
- Honda CR-V vs Mitsubishi Outlander: Two Japanese SUVs Built for Family Life
- Toyota Crown Crossover vs Lexus ES: The Saloon That Grew Tall and the One That Stayed Low
- Lexus LS vs Mercedes-Benz S-Class: The Flagship Duel, Bought From Japan
- Subaru Impreza Sport vs Mazda Axela Sport: The Grip Specialist and the Driver's Hatchback
- Importing a Toyota Supra: prices and costs
Photo credits
- Toyota Supra: Photo: Alexander Migl / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Toyota Supra: Photo: Alexander Migl / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
- Nissan Fairlady Z: Photo: TTTNIS / Wikimedia Commons, CC0