Mazda Roadster vs BMW Z4: The Lightweight Purist and the Powerful Grand Tourer
Both are two-seat, rear-wheel-drive convertibles sold new in Japan with right-hand drive. One weighs barely a tonne. The other has up to six cylinders and a lot more muscle.
By the Japan to Ireland editors · · 4 min read


In short: In the three months to 19 September 2026, 1,125 Mazda Roadsters sold at Japanese auctions at a median of €9,194, against 160 BMW Z4s at €2,828. The BMW Z4 is the cheaper buy by about €6,367 at auction, before shipping, VAT, VRT and fees. Our verdict is at the end of this article.
The Mazda Roadster, known in Europe as the MX-5, is the best-selling two-seat sports car in history. Its idea has barely changed since 1989: a light, simple, rear-wheel-drive convertible that is affordable to buy and fun to drive at normal speeds. The BMW Z4 takes a different approach. It is larger, heavier and much more powerful, a sports car with grand touring ambitions.
Both are sold new in Japan with right-hand drive, and both appear regularly at Japanese auctions. For Irish buyers, they offer two very different ways of enjoying a convertible on roads where the sun appears less often than we would like.
The generations most commonly found today are the fourth-generation ND Roadster, launched in 2015, and the G29 Z4, launched in 2019. Older E89 Z4s, made from 2009 to 2016 with a folding metal roof, also turn up often.
The specs
| Mazda Roadster | BMW Z4 | |
|---|---|---|
| Generation most imported | ND (MX-5), 2015 on | G29, 2019 on (E89, 2009–2016, also common) |
| Engine(s) | 1.5 petrol; 2.0 petrol (RF) | 2.0 turbo petrol; 3.0 six-cylinder turbo petrol |
| Gearbox | 6-speed manual or 6-speed auto | 8-speed auto |
| Drive | Rear | Rear |
| Seats | 2 | 2 |
| Length | About 3,915 mm | About 4,325 mm |
| Roof | Soft top, or RF folding hard top | Soft top |
| Import duty to Ireland | 0% possible (Japan-built, with proof of origin) | 10% (not built in Japan) |
What each car is
The ND Roadster is the lightest MX-5 in decades. Japanese-market cars use a 1.5-litre petrol engine, while the RF, with its folding hard top, uses a 2.0-litre. Both are available with a six-speed manual or automatic. The car is small, simple and focused on driving.
The G29 Z4 shares its platform with the Toyota Supra. In Japan it is offered as the sDrive20i, with a 2.0-litre turbo four, and the M40i, with a 3.0-litre turbo six. All use an eight-speed automatic. It has a fabric roof, unlike the E89's folding hard top.
How they drive
The Roadster is a joy at legal speeds. The steering is light and precise, the gearbox is one of the best manuals available, and the car feels alive on a twisting road. It is not fast in a straight line, but it does not need to be. On a quiet back road in Wicklow or Kerry, it delivers more fun than many more powerful cars.
The Z4 is fast, especially the M40i, which has very strong acceleration. It is more stable and refined at high speeds and better suited to long motorway trips. It is also heavier and less playful than the Roadster at lower speeds. The ride is firm, particularly on M Sport versions with large wheels.
Inside and practicality
The Roadster's cabin is snug. Taller drivers may find it tight, and storage space is limited. The boot is small, enough for a weekend's luggage but not much more. The soft top is easy to raise and lower by hand.
The Z4 is roomier. Its cabin is more luxurious and better suited to taller drivers, and its boot is larger. The electric roof opens and closes quickly. It feels more like a premium car, and it is.
The roof question deserves a moment of thought in an Irish climate. A fabric roof on either car is well insulated and seals well when looked after, but it needs cleaning and occasional proofing, and the drain channels must be kept clear or water finds its way into the cabin. The Roadster RF and the older E89 Z4 offer a hard top for buyers who will park on the street through a long, wet winter. The RF is a little noisier with the roof down, the E89 heavier, but both feel more like a coupé on a cold January morning.
Running costs and reliability
The Roadster is cheap to run for a sports car. It is light, simple and uses little fuel, and the 1.5-litre engine sits in a reasonable CO2 band. Reliability is generally excellent, though some early ND manual gearboxes have been the subject of complaints, so test the gear change carefully.
The Z4 is more expensive to run. It uses more fuel, needs more expensive parts and sits in higher tax bands, especially the M40i. Reliability is generally good, but repairs will cost more than for the Roadster.
What to check at a Japanese auction
For both cars, check the roof carefully for tears, leaks and mechanism faults. Look for signs of track use or modifications, which are common on sports cars. The auction sheet will note any accident damage.
For the Roadster, check the manual gearbox for smooth operation and look for rust on older examples, though it is rare on cars from most of Japan. For the Z4, check for warning lights, oil leaks and the condition of the run-flat tyres. On the E89, check the folding metal roof operates smoothly.
The verdict
Buy the Roadster if you want pure, simple driving pleasure at low cost. It is the better car for back-road fun and the easier one to own.
Buy the Z4 if you want more power, more comfort and more space. It is the better choice for long journeys and for buyers who want a premium car. The M40i offers performance the Roadster cannot match.
Frequently asked questions
Is the Mazda Roadster the same as the MX-5?
Yes. Roadster is the name used in Japan for the car sold in Europe as the MX-5.
Which Z4 is most common at Japanese auctions?
The G29 from 2019 and the older E89 from 2009 to 2016 are both commonly found.
Is the Roadster available as an automatic?
Yes. Both the soft top and RF are available with a six-speed automatic in Japan.
Keep reading
- Mercedes-Benz E-Class vs BMW 5 Series: The Executive Saloon Rivalry, Bought Used from Japan
- Mazda CX-8 vs Mazda CX-60: The Seven-Seat Family Hauler and the Six-Cylinder Upstart
- Toyota 86 vs Subaru BRZ: Twins From the Same Factory, Separated by Suspension and Personality
- BMW X1 vs Audi Q3: Two German Crossovers That Spent Their Early Years in Tokyo Traffic
- Toyota SAI vs Lexus HS 250h: Twin Hybrid Saloons That Japan Kept to Itself
Photo credits
- Mazda Roadster: Photo: Alexander-93 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
- BMW Z4: Photo: Alexander-93 / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0