Mercedes-Benz GLC vs BMW X3: Comfort Against Agility in the German Mid-Size SUV Class
The GLC and the X3 have dominated the premium mid-size SUV class for a decade. In Japan both were sold in right-hand drive, mostly with diesel engines and all-wheel drive.
By the Japan to Ireland editors · · 4 min read


In short: In the three months to 19 September 2026, 281 Mercedes-Benz GLCs sold at Japanese auctions at a median of €8,781, against 627 BMW X3s at €5,506. The BMW X3 is the cheaper buy by about €3,275 at auction, before shipping, VAT, VRT and fees. Our verdict is at the end of this article.
Mercedes-Benz and BMW have been measuring themselves against each other for most of a century, and in the premium SUV market that rivalry is sharpest at this size. The GLC arrived in 2015 to replace the boxy GLK and quickly became one of the best-selling cars Mercedes makes. The third-generation X3, coded G01 and introduced in 2017, moved BMW's mid-size SUV further upmarket with a larger body and a much better cabin.
Both were sold new in Japan in right-hand drive, and both turn up at Japanese auctions in numbers, often with modest mileage and dealer service books. For an Irish buyer they represent two distinct approaches to the same brief. Mercedes leans towards comfort and calm. BMW leans towards the driver.
The specs
| Mercedes-Benz GLC | BMW X3 | |
|---|---|---|
| Generation most imported | X253, 2015–2022 | G01, 2017 on |
| Engines (Japan) | 2.0 petrol, diesel, plug-in hybrid | 2.0 petrol, 2.0 diesel, 3.0 six-cylinder diesel |
| Gearbox | 9-speed automatic | 8-speed automatic |
| Drive | 4MATIC AWD on most versions | xDrive AWD |
| Seats | 5 | 5 |
| Length (approx.) | 4,660 mm | 4,710 mm |
| Coupé version | GLC Coupé | Sold separately as the X4 |
| Import duty to Ireland | 10% (not built in Japan) | 10% (not built in Japan) |
Positioning
The GLC is, in effect, a taller C-Class of the same era, and its cabin, electronics and engines come from that car. Japanese buyers mostly chose the 220d 4MATIC diesel, the 2.0-litre petrol versions and the 350e plug-in hybrid. The GLC Coupé, with its sloping roofline, shares the same mechanical base and gives up some rear headroom and boot space for its looks.
The X3 sits on BMW's CLAR architecture, the same family of components used under the 5 Series. In Japan the xDrive20d diesel was the most popular version by some distance, with the xDrive20i petrol below it and the six-cylinder M40d diesel at the top. All Japanese X3s of this generation have xDrive all-wheel drive.
How they drive
The GLC is quiet and supple. Its suspension soaks up broken surfaces with real composure, the steering is light and accurate, and the nine-speed automatic shifts almost imperceptibly. Cars fitted with the optional air suspension ride especially well. On a long run down the M7 it feels more like a luxury saloon than an SUV.
The X3 is the sharper tool. Its steering has more weight, its body is held more tightly through bends and its eight-speed automatic responds quickly to the throttle. The penalty is ride quality. M Sport cars on large wheels and run-flat tyres feel every pothole on a rural road, and a car on smaller wheels makes more sense for Irish surfaces. On a winding N road, though, the BMW is the one you will enjoy.
Inside and practicality
The GLC's cabin is the more elegant. The materials are rich, the wood and metal trims are well judged and the design has aged gracefully. Rear space is adequate for adults, and the boot is a sensible size for a family weekend.
The X3 is a little larger inside, with more rear legroom and a slightly bigger boot. Its interior is more businesslike than the Mercedes, but it is well built, logically arranged and easy to use, and the iDrive rotary controller remains one of the best ways to work an infotainment screen while driving.
Running costs and reliability
Both are premium cars with premium running costs. Servicing and parts cost more than for mainstream brands, and an independent specialist is usually the sensible route once the car is a few years old. The diesel versions use the least fuel, but they should do regular longer runs to keep their particulate filters clean.
Both have broadly solid records for their class. Air suspension on the GLC is a known cost if a strut or compressor fails, and its many electronic systems should all be working at purchase. The X3's four-cylinder diesel is well regarded, and run-flat tyres are the main recurring expense.
What to check at auction
Read the auction sheet for notes on warning lights, suspension faults or electronic issues. Aim for an overall grade of 4 or better with interior grade B or better. Check the condition of the wheels and tyres, which are expensive at these sizes, and note any windscreen replacements on cars with camera-based driver aids.
Confirm the service history, ideally with Japanese dealer stamps, and check that the infotainment and parking cameras work. Rust is rarely a concern on Japanese-used cars of this age, though underside photographs of snow-region cars are worth asking for.
The verdict
Buy the GLC if you value comfort, refinement and a beautiful cabin, and most of your driving is on motorways and main roads. A 220d on standard suspension and moderate wheels is a calm, efficient long-distance car.
Buy the X3 if you enjoy driving and want an SUV that handles almost like a saloon, with a little more space in the back. The xDrive20d is the sensible choice. The M40d is for drivers who want real pace and accept the costs that come with it.
Frequently asked questions
Are Japanese GLCs and X3s right-hand drive?
Yes. Both were sold new in Japan in right-hand drive.
Which is more comfortable?
The GLC generally rides more softly, especially with air suspension and smaller wheels.
Which has more space?
The X3 has slightly more rear legroom and a slightly larger boot.
Keep reading
- Subaru Stella vs Daihatsu Move Conte: Two Small Cars From One Factory, With Very Different Moods
- Daihatsu Wake vs Mitsubishi eK Space: How Tall Can a Kei Car Get Before It Stops Making Sense?
- Nissan GT-R vs Lexus LC: Japan's Two Flagship Performance Cars, and Two Ideas of Speed
- Mercedes-Benz V-Class vs Toyota Hiace Wagon: The Executive Shuttle and the Workhorse With Windows
- Nissan Teana vs Toyota Premio: Two Quiet Japanese Saloons for Drivers Who Hate Fuss
- Importing a BMW X3: prices and costs
Photo credits
- Mercedes-Benz GLC: Photo: Alexander Migl / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
- BMW X3: Photo: Alexander Migl / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0